| Year |
Winner |
Loser |
| 2011 |
Wizards (NL)
Pat Jennings |
Tigers (AL)
Richard Deyerle |
| 2010 |
Venom (NL)
Jeff Easton |
Hunters (AL)
Steven Deyerle |
| 2009 |
Colts (NL)
Earl Estes |
Tigers (AL)
Richard Deyerle |
| 2008 |
Wizards (NL)
Pat Jennings |
T-Birds (AL)
Mike Thurston |
| 2007 |
Hunters (AL)
Steven Deyerle |
Bimbos (NL)
Keith Gilmore |
| 2006 |
TazDevils (AL)
Tim Turner |
Wizards (NL)
Pat Jennings |
| 2005 |
T-Birds (AL)
Mike Thurston |
Mad Hatters (NL)
Dave Caddell |
| 2004 |
Tigers (AL)
Richard Deyerle |
Ducks (NL)
Don Leigers |
| 2003 |
Tigers (AL)
Richard Deyerle |
RoadRunners (NL)
Jim Proffitt |
| 2002 |
Tigers (AL)
Richard Deyerle |
RoadRunners (NL)
Jim Proffitt |
| 2001 |
Tigers (AL)
Richard Deyerle |
Buffalo Chips (NL)
Chip Foster |
| 2000 |
Bulls (NL)
Pat Manuel |
Tigers (AL)
Richard Deyerle |
| 1999 |
Mad Hatters (NL)
Dave Caddell |
Tigers (AL)
Richard Deyerle |
| 1998 |
Wizards (NL)
Pat Jennings |
Mercenaries (AL)
Chip Foster |
| 1997 |
Mad Hatters (NL)
Dave Caddell |
Black Sox (AL)
Terry Maguire |
| 1996 |
Twins (AL)
Paul Blocher |
Outlaws (NL)
Ed Orgon |
| 1995 |
Black Sox (AL)
Terry Maguire |
Ducks (NL)
Jim Mellilo |
| 1994 |
Mad Hatters (NL)
Dave Caddell |
Lawgivers (AL)
Terry Maguire |
| 1993 |
Tigers (AL)
Richard Deyerle |
RoadRunners (NL)
Jim Proffitt |
| 1992 |
Tigers (AL)
Richard Deyerle |
Seminoles (NL)
Marty Quinn |
| 1991 |
Tigers (AL)
Richard Deyerle |
Outlaws (NL)
Pat Jennings & Mike Thurston |
| 1990 |
Barbarians (NL)
Jami Denton & J. Walker |
Tigers (AL)
Richard Deyerle |
| 1989 |
Tigers (AL)
Richard Deyerle |
Barbarians (NL)
Jami Denton & J. Walker |
| 1988 |
Tigers (AL)
Richard Deyerle |
RoadRunners (NL)
Jim Proffitt |
| 1987 |
Whales (AL)
Randy Shavis |
Mastros (NL)
Jami Denton & J. Walker |
| 1986 |
Fire Ants (NL)
Chris Brandt |
Tigers (AL)
Richard Deyerle |
| 1985 |
Tigers (AL)
Richard Deyerle |
Mastros (NL)
Ron Smith |
| 1984 |
Mastros (NL)
Ron Smith |
Bees (AL)
Ron Smith |
| 1983 |
Killer Ducks
Myron Pecora |
Destroyers
Landon Simpson |
